My Fedora 15 Pre-release experience


Today, it become clear that Fedora 15 will be released on May 24th :). It is an interesting release, specially as the first official Linux distribution coming with GNOME 3. Besides, it comes with a number of interesting features including (but not limited to): KDE 4.6, systemd, power management enhancements, Robotics Suite, Retrace Server, Better SPICE support, Dynamic Firewall and GDB 7.3. You can find the complete list of new features at Fedora 15’s Feature Page.

I have tried Fedora 15 since its Alpha release, and started using more seriously since the first test compose of the final release. I generally really like this release, however it has a number of issues too because of the arrival of the new GNOME 3. Let’s start with the annoying parts first!

I have already talked about some GNOME 3  design decisions that I don’t like. I use my laptop as a “computer”, and its main job is … computing rather than being an interactive device! So, when I close its lid I don’t want all my downloads or processes to be stopped; and I know that there are many like me. Fortunately, you can install gnome-tweak-tool to be able to easily change this setting.

The most annoying part of my experience were these 2 problems: the first on is a problem that I have faced since the first Fedora Desktop Test Day. From time to time, gnome-shell starts to eat my CPU time, making the desktop sluggish and my laptop very hot. This is really annoying, and I am forced to restart gnome-shell (Alt+F2 and then ‘r’) so that it goes back to the normal state. The next one is that currently, you are unable to connect to Ad-Hoc wireless networks in Fedora 15 using NetworkManager due to this bug. It really annoys me, but at least command line still works! 😦

Except the tray icons of Java applications which float around in GNOME 3, almost everything is fine with it … as while as I use en_US locale. As soon as I switch to fa_IR locale, problems appear: simply, gnome-shell crashes immediately! Using one of two available workarounds, I can actually login to gnome-shell. Then, a number of issues appear, with the third one being so problematic that makes gnome-shell in fa_IR locale almost unusable and forced me to switch to en_US locate for the time being.

OK, these were all that really hit me with this release. It’s probably not that bad for such a release with big changes! 🙂 However, we will probably delay our Parsidora 15 release until some of all of these issues are solved.

Now, the interesting parts! After using GNOME 3 in Fedora for a while, I think I like it! It looks great (while probably sometimes it looks too gray, specially in nautilus) and feels good! Fonts are looking a bit different in Fedora 15, due to some font rendering enhancements merged in freetype and in Fedora. Initially I thought that I won’t like this change, but now I like it! Also, the new notification system is much better and less intrusive. Despite the mentioned problems, I’ll definitely switch to Fedora 15! 😛

GNOME 3 screenshot with a non-default theme

I have installed some gnome-shell extensions and gnome-shell themes to customize it a little (while the default gnome-shell theme is also beautiful). Also, since GNOME 3 doesn’t provide “Type Break” settings in its keyboard preferences anymore, I installed DrWritght which is the same application provided for GNOME 3. As said earlier, gnome-tweak-tool also provides some useful features :).

Finally, I really liked Fedora 15’s Retrace Server feature. It finally made ABRT a useful tool for me! Till now, I usually disabled ABRT, since it needed to download many large -debuginfo packages to provide any usable services. But this is no longer needed, and you can generate useful bug reports using ABRT without installing any extra packages since retrace server can do that job for you. 🙂 I have already created two bug reports using this facility, something that I were able to do for the first time! This is a great feature indeed 😛

Update: This bugs are solved now: Ad-Hoc connection problem, gnome shell crash in fa_IR locale and corrupted nautilus menu entries in RTL locales

Advertisements

12 responses to this post.

  1. Sorry we did not get more focus on these issues. It would be great in future if you could propose really major issues when using fa_IR as release blocker or NTH bugs – see https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/QA:SOP_blocker_bug_process and https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/QA:SOP_nth_bug_process – so that we will be able to give them attention. We rely on testers like you to catch major issues in the non-English locales, as it’s difficult for a non-native speaker to use the desktop well enough to catch and report these. thanks a lot!

    Reply

    • Thanks a lot for your attention, and sorry for not reporting the issues as blocker or NTH bugs. To be honest, I felt that the number of users is not that much and they’ll be rejected. However, I should have reported them anyway. I’ll do it in future 🙂

      Thanks again.

      Reply

  2. I think that bug is related to utf usage of Persian day names

    Reply

  3. Does it always happen, or on some occasions, and is the situation the same with ar? Because I don’t remember facing such problems with arabic (I only tested gnome3 for a while)

    Reply

    • Sorry, which one? The crash is only for fa_IR, but I remember seeing the nautilus menu problem in Arabic too. And the problem with loosing focus, well it happens always after using the shell for some time.

      Reply

  4. I have been using fedora 15 since beta release is launched. It’s great especially GNOME 3. But… later KDE4 is more comfortable than GNOME 3

    Reply

  5. Wonderfull review
    But my attention was attracted to your theme. What theme do you use? 😐 so cute

    Reply

  6. wow, didn’t know we can change thems in GNOME 3. How did you change that theme?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: